UrRong. While it is true that pronouns are not necessarily required linguistically, that does not mean that they should be discarded entirely. Pronouns serve an important purpose in helping to identify and describe gender identity, which is a major part of how people express themselves and relate to one another. Without pronouns, it would be difficult to communicate effectively about gender and identity.
In addition, the idea of using “they/them” or “ze/zir” as gender-neutral pronouns is not an attempt to “dismantle gender as the social construct that it is”. Rather, it is an effort to make language more inclusive by providing alternative pronouns to those who identify outside of the gender binary. These pronouns are not intended to replace traditional pronouns, but rather to provide additional options to those who wish to express their gender in a different way.
Furthermore, calling everyone “it” is highly dehumanizing. By reducing people to mere objects, it strips away their individual identity and treats them as less than human. This not only fails to recognize the unique identities and experiences of individuals, but also reinforces the idea that certain people are less valuable than others, which is the very definition of oppression and discrimination.
In conclusion, while it is true that pronouns are not required linguistically, that does not mean that they should be discarded entirely. Pronouns play an important role in helping to identify and describe gender identity, and alternative pronouns allow people to express themselves in a way that is more inclusive and respectful of their unique identities.
